11
Nov
How long can you delay roof replacement? As long as the water stays on top of the shingles, and not one season longer. There is no safe number of years. A worn roof that still sheds water can often wait for a good season and a written quote. A roof that lets water reach the wood under it is on a different clock, and every wet month adds work to the job you’re putting off.
Questions about your own roof? Call Adem at (705) 770-0636.
The question to ask is not “how old is it”. It’s “where is the water going”. This post sorts the signs into three groups: the ones that can wait, the ones that shorten the wait, and the ones that end it. When the time comes, our roof replacement page sets out how the new roof goes on.
| Sign | What it means | How long the roof can wait |
|---|---|---|
| Dark streaks, faded colour, a few granules in the eavestrough | The roof is ageing, but it still sheds water | A season |
| Curled edges, bald spots, moss, cracked shingles | The shingles are losing the fight | This year |
| Water inside the house, or shingles on the lawn | Water is getting through now | Now |
The roof deck is the layer of plywood or similar sheathing nailed across the rafters. It sits under the underlayment and the shingles, and it is what every nail holds on to. You can’t see it from the ground or from inside the house.
The shingles are there to keep the deck dry. While they do that job, an old roof is mostly a question of looks and timing. Once they stop, the deck takes the water. Wet plywood goes soft, and soft plywood does not hold a nail.
The damage also shows up somewhere other than the cause. Water runs down the deck and along the rafters before it drips. The stain on your bedroom ceiling may trace back to a valley or a pipe well uphill of it. That’s one more reason a slow leak can run longer than anyone knows.
Some signs of age are real but slow. They are a reason to book an inspection and plan the job, not a reason to panic.
If these are all you see, you likely have time. Use it to get the job on the calendar for warm weather. Our post on the best season for roof replacement covers why new shingles want sunny weeks to seal.
These signs mean the shingles are losing the fight. The roof may still be dry inside, but the margin is going.
Here’s a check from the lawn. Take a pair of binoculars and look along the bottom row of shingles on each slope. Then look at the slope that gets the most sun. If the edges curl up and the surface looks bare in patches on more than one slope, plan for this year, not next. Our post on the signs you need a roof repair walks through the ladder and attic checks too.
Water inside the house ends the debate. Owens Corning says that once a roof can no longer repel water, damage to the roof deck, insulation and drywall, or mould growth, can develop quickly.
Check from the attic hatch after a heavy rain. Don’t crawl out onto the insulation. Shine a flashlight along the underside of the deck near the eaves, around the chimney and under the valleys. Look for dark patches on the wood, mould or deteriorated insulation. Dry, pale wood is good news. Dark wood or a drip means water is getting through now.
Shingles on the lawn after a storm are the other hard stop. Shingles that blow off can leave large areas of a roof unprotected from rain or snow.
An old roof can make it through a dry August. Winter is where waiting goes wrong around here.
Lake-effect snow off Georgian Bay can blanket roofs from Wasaga Beach to Collingwood and inland to Stayner. The National Research Council’s digest on ice on roofs says the main mechanism for snow melting is heat loss from the building through the roof. The melt water drains down the slope under the snow to the eaves, where some of it freezes. That ice holds back the next melt. On a roof with curled or cracked shingles at the eaves, the water behind the ice has an easy way in.
Cottages heated only on weekends get this too. Each time the heat comes on, the snow can melt and refreeze at the edge. Nobody is there midweek to see the drip.
If you see big icicles every winter, look at the attic before you blame the shingles. Warm air reaching the roof is the usual cause, and our page on attic insulation and ventilation explains the fix.
Putting the job off until late fall has its own cost. New shingles need warmth from the sun to seal, so a roof done in the cold can sit with only its nails holding until spring.
Many owners plan to wait until a storm makes it an insurance claim. The Insurance Bureau of Canada is clear on the limit. It says the gradual deterioration of shingle roofing is natural and expected, and therefore not an insured peril. It also says a home insurance policy is not a maintenance contract.
The bureau adds a point that matters for an old roof. Insurers generally prefer that roofs are updated within 20 years. If a roof has reached its lifespan and leaks, the bureau says the interior damage may be covered, but the roof itself would not be insured.
So waiting for wear to finish the roof does not move the bill to the insurer. Read your own policy, and see our post on roof repair vs insurance deductible for when a claim is worth making.
We get it. A new roof is a big decision, and a repair is easier to fit into this year. Often a repair is the right call: one leak at a pipe boot or a few shingles lost in a windstorm can be fixed, and the full roof can wait for the right season.
The one fact to weigh is the roof around the repair. A new part woven into tired shingles can only hold as well as they do. If the same slope needs work every year, the repair is buying less time each round. Our roof repair page sets out when a repair still makes sense.
Nobody sees the deck until tear-off. On a 705 Roofing replacement, the old shingles and underlayment come off one section at a time, so the deck is never left open to rain longer than needed. If we find rotten, soft or damaged decking, we replace it before the new roof system goes on.
That’s where a long wait shows up. A roof replaced while it is still dry may need little or no new plywood. A roof that leaked for several winters can need sheets cut out at the eaves, in the valleys and around the chimney. Our page on roof plywood replacement explains how that part of the job works.
If the attic is dry after heavy rain and no shingles are missing, often yes. Check the attic again after the spring melt. If the deck shows dark patches, the year is over.
For a dry roof with worn shingles, waiting for warm weather is reasonable. A roof with water coming in should get a repair now, and the full replacement can follow in the warm stretch.
Not for wear. The Insurance Bureau of Canada says gradual deterioration of shingle roofing is not an insured peril. Storm damage is a separate question, so read your policy.
It can. A roof that leaks long enough to soften the deck needs that plywood replaced before the new shingles go on.
This post can tell you which signs can wait. It can’t tell you whether the deck under your valleys is still sound, or how far a slow leak has run along the rafters. A roof visit settles that. If you see water inside or shingles on the lawn, have someone look at it before the next storm.
To have 705 Roofing look at yours, call (705) 770-0636 and ask for the free roof inspection and a written quote. We work in Wasaga Beach, Collingwood, Stayner, Barrie, Midland and Simcoe County.